A couple of us went to the RSA on Monday to listen to Jaron Lanier talk about his new book You are not a Gadget.
This book is critical of web 2.0, crowd dynamics, creative commons and all that it has spawned. In essence, and the talk was far more complex and philosophical than this, Jaron was reacting to the pervasive mantra of Web 2.0’s most ardent supporters. This mantra is probably best typified by Chris Anderson’s new book Free, and the free-conomics it persuades us to believe in. Jaron, and bear in mind he was until recently banging this drum the loudest, believes that Web 2.0 has had its chance to define the culture and economics of the future. But has failed.
He cites Journalism and the music industry as proof that the way we use this technology has devalued human enterprise, creativity, and intellect and cannot sustain itself. As he says, “the vast majority of journalists, musicians, artists and filmmakers” are “staring into career oblivion because of our failed digital idealism”. Yes, yes, he knows that there are lots of examples of bands giving their music away for free and making money on branded pencil cases and whatnot. But as a whole he believes the industry and the creative people who work within it cannot be sustained this way. This is an important point, for Jaron is not arguing against particular success stories – ‘more power to you’ he says, he is arguing against the system as a whole.
Perhaps Jaron will find it amusing that I also went to the launch of Chris Anderson’s book where one of the other speakers invited to add meat to the bones of Chris’ free-conomics argument was the editor of The London Paper. The London Paper went out of business shortly after he spoke.
Is Jaron right? Well, by the timethat there are enough people who believe he is, it will probably be too late.
Anyway, here is your free blog post. Would you now like a website?
Buy the book here
Some FAQ here
And a good review in NYT that discusses the other implications of his point








